An agent promises to sell your home fast or buy it themselves. Here is what that guarantee really costs Tampa Bay sellers, and the questions to ask before you sign anything.
Yes, there is almost always a catch. Programs that promise to sell your home in 90 days or buy it themselves typically come with a buyout price well below market value, a list price the agent controls, scheduled price reductions, and much higher fees than a standard listing. My advice has not changed in more than a decade: run, don’t walk, away from any Realtor who leads with a guarantee instead of a track record. Welcome back to my Ask a Realtor section! This question first landed in my inbox in 2012, and I still get some version of it every year. A Tampa seller wrote to me: “I need to sell my Tampa house, as I have found another house already.” An agent had promised to sell it in 29 days or buy it himself. Sounds great! Her question was simple. Is there a catch? Here is the thing nobody says out loud. No Realtor WANTS to buy your home if they can’t sell it. The guarantee is not designed to be used. It is a deceptive marketing tool designed to get the agent through your front door, and in my opinion, it’s a bait and switch. In 2026 the postcards say 90 days, the bench ads say Guaranteed Sold, and the apps hand you an instant cash number before you finish your coffee. The packaging changed. The math underneath has barely moved.
I have heard this story from sellers so many times I could act it out. You see the ad, you book the appointment, and the agent sits down at your kitchen table with the guaranteed sale contract. Then the fine print comes out. The commission on the guaranteed option is far higher than you expected (in the guaranteed offers sellers have shown me, 10% is not unusual), and the agent, not you, sets the asking price, usually well below market value with more reductions baked in down the road. WHAT? You sit back, appalled. And right on cue: “But wait, there’s another option we offer!” That option is a standard listing agreement at a normal commission, where you price your home at market value and there is no guarantee at all. You are so relieved that you sign it on the spot. Now wait, think about this for a minute. Did you fall for it? The guaranteed contract was never meant to be signed. Its only job was to lure you in. And is this really the Realtor you want representing you? What do you know about their sales track record, their marketing, or anything else they actually do for sellers? If the answer is nothing except the guarantee, that tells you a lot. You just got bait and switched.
Most guaranteed sale offers in Tampa Bay fall into three buckets. The first is the classic agent guarantee. A local agent or team signs a listing agreement promising to sell your home within a set window, or buy it themselves at a price fixed on day one. That fixed price is the whole story, and it is typically set well under what the agent expects your home to sell for on the open market. The commission is the other half of the story. In the guaranteed offers sellers have shown me over the years, a 10% commission on the guaranteed option is not unusual. The second is the instant cash offer. Companies like Opendoor and Offerpad (often called iBuyers) make an offer online, send someone to inspect, deduct for repairs, and charge a service fee. Each company publishes its own fee (Opendoor lists its service charge on its pricing page), and closing costs and repair deductions come on top of it, so compare the net number you would keep, not the headline fee. Remember Zillow Offers? Zillow shut that program down in 2021 after it lost money buying homes. Speed has a price, and someone always pays it. The third is the guaranteed offer or buy before you sell program, offered by some brokerages, lenders, and tech companies. You get a backup cash offer so you can purchase your next home before your current one sells. It can be genuinely useful, but the backup price and program fees are the cost of that convenience, and they should be compared line by line against a traditional sale. Why are these ads everywhere again? Because they always come back when the market shifts. Many St. Petersburg and Tampa sellers are competing with more listings than they saw during the 2021 and 2022 frenzy, and condo owners in particular are feeling it. When sellers are nervous, certainty sells. Before you trade equity for a promise, start with a professional home valuation built on actual recent sales near you, not a buyout formula. In the guaranteed offers sellers have shown me, buyout prices commonly land somewhere around 5% to 15% below what the agent believes your home is worth, and some contracts still deduct commission and closing costs from that number. On a $750,000 St. Pete home, a 10% haircut is $75,000. If the contract also deducts a 10% commission, the total can climb to roughly $140,000. That is not insurance. That is a very expensive deductible. Many guarantees only apply if you list at the agent’s recommended price and accept scheduled price reductions every few weeks. By the time the buyout clause could kick in, your list price may already be sitting right on top of the buyout number, which means a regular buyer often takes the home first and the guarantee never costs the agent a dime. The guaranteed version usually carries a higher commission than the standard listing, and in the offers sellers have shown me, a 10% commission on a guaranteed sale is not unusual. Some programs add administrative, inspection, or staging fees. Back in 2012, one agent running these ads admitted to me that fewer than 1% of his clients chose the guaranteed option. The guarantee gets the appointment. The regular listing agreement is what gets signed. Programs often exclude homes that need repairs, unique or historic homes, waterfront properties, homes in high risk flood zones or with prior flood damage, and older condos facing milestone inspections or special assessments. In St. Pete, that can rule out Old Northeast bungalows, Snell Isle and Shore Acres waterfront homes, and plenty of downtown condo buildings. If you own one of these, you need a waterfront listing specialist who knows how to price and position it, not a gimmick that excludes it. Some guarantees only apply if you also buy your next home with the same agent or team, sometimes within a specific time frame. That is two commissions tied to one promise. Read that clause twice, especially if you are relocating out of the area. Decline a showing, turn down an offer within a certain percentage of list price, skip a requested repair, or let the listing lapse, and the guarantee may disappear. Long listing terms and cancellation fees can make the agreement hard to walk away from even when it is not working for you.
I am not going to pretend these programs never help anyone. A guaranteed floor price can be worth paying for if you have a corporate relocation with a hard start date, an estate that needs to settle on a deadline, a divorce where both parties need a defined number, or you simply cannot carry two mortgages while you wait for the right buyer. Even then, compare your options before you sign. A relocation package from your employer, a well prepared and properly priced listing, a bridge loan or other financing (talk to a lender about your specific situation), or a handful of investor cash offers reviewed alongside an agent’s market analysis may get you the same certainty with far less equity left on the table. A seller consultation is the fastest way to put real numbers next to each path so you are choosing with your eyes open.
Don’t sign anything yet. If you are seriously considering one of these programs, get answers to these questions in writing before you commit. 1. What is the exact buyout price, stated in dollars, and is it in the signed agreement? That last question is my favorite. Watch their face when you ask it. The answer tells you everything. For more, see my list of questions to ask when interviewing a real estate agent. Also remember that commissions have always been negotiable, and the 2024 industry settlement made that more visible than ever, so do not treat any fee as fixed. Because every contract and property is different, have a Florida real estate attorney review the agreement, and verify flood zone, insurance, and condo association details for your specific address with the appropriate official sources before relying on any guarantee. You have probably seen the slogan on a yard sign, a bench or a postcard: Your Home Sold Guaranteed or I’ll Buy It. Some agents and franchised teams build their whole brand around it. The promise can be real in the narrow sense that it is written into a contract. What decides whether it is worth anything is the fine print behind it: the buyout price in dollars, who sets the list price, the price reduction schedule, the fees, and the conditions that cancel the guarantee. A few things are worth knowing before you call the number on the sign. The guaranteed price is usually a separate, lower number than the list price in the ad. Some versions only promise a sale at a price “agreeable to you” or at a percentage of a value their side chooses. Some require you to buy your next home through the same team. Ask for the guarantee terms in writing before the listing appointment, then put them next to a standard listing and a real home valuation so you can see what the promise costs. This is not a new pitch. I talked about it on TV years ago (see my Bay News 9 segment on guaranteed sale programs), and the math has hardly changed. If you want a second set of eyes on the numbers, I am happy to walk through them with you. The legal terms of the contract are a job for a Florida real estate attorney, but I can show you what your home is likely to sell for on the open market so you can compare.
BEWARE the Guaranteed Sale Program: Sold or We Buy It – Here’s the Catch
The Short Answer: Yes, There Is a Catch
The Bait and Switch: How It Plays Out at Your Kitchen Table
How Guaranteed Home Sale Programs Work in 2026
The Fine Print: 6 Catches Sellers Miss
The Buyout Price Is Below Market
The Agent Controls Your List Price
Higher Commission and Extra Fees
Your Home May Not Qualify
You May Have to Buy Through Them Too
Conditions That Void the Guarantee
When a Guaranteed Sale Might Actually Make Sense
Don't Sign Until You Ask These 9 Questions
2. How was the list price calculated, and which recent comparable sales support it?
3. Is there a required price reduction schedule, and am I obligated to accept it?
4. What is the commission and fee structure for the guaranteed option compared to a standard listing, and are fees deducted from the buyout price?
5. What conditions void the guarantee, including inspection findings, repairs, flood history, condo association documents, or showing availability?
6. Am I required to buy my next home through you for the guarantee to apply?
7. Who actually buys the home if it does not sell, and can they show proof of funds?
8. How long is the listing agreement, and what does it cost to cancel?
9. How many sellers in the past year actually had their homes purchased under your guarantee?
Is 'Your Home Sold Guaranteed or I'll Buy It' Real?
Here is the honest truth after nearly 20 years of selling homes in St. Pete and Tampa Bay. The best guarantee you can get is accurate pricing based on real data, smart preparation, and serious exposure to the right buyers. Homes that are priced correctly from day one typically sell faster and closer to list price than homes that start high and chase the market down with reductions, which is exactly the strategy many guarantee programs build in. So skip the gimmick and ask any agent you interview for their list price to sale price ratio and average days on market for homes like yours. Isn’t that figure a lot more important than some bogus guarantee? That is how I approach every listing. My team pairs a data driven price with professional marketing and reach that goes beyond the portals, including our 44,000 member Facebook community where our listings get in front of local buyers who are actively looking. If you want to see what that looks like for your home, learn more about working with a St. Petersburg listing agent who would rather earn your sale than sell you a gimmick.
Many are legitimate in the sense that the promise is written into a contract. The catch is the terms. The buyout price is typically set well below market value, and conditions like required price reductions, higher commissions, and eligibility rules mean the agent rarely ends up buying the home. Read the full agreement before signing.
Buyout prices are commonly set somewhere in the range of 5% to 15% below the agent’s estimate of market value, and some contracts also deduct commission and closing costs. In my experience, a 10% commission on the guaranteed option is not unusual. The exact figure depends on the individual agreement and property, so ask for the buyout price in dollars, in writing, before you sign.
They can be faster and more convenient, but they are usually not better financially. Total iBuyer fees of 6% to 7% are common, repair deductions are common after inspection, and independent analyses suggest sellers often net less than they might on the open market. Compare any cash offer against a professional market analysis before deciding.
If every condition in the agreement has been met, the agent or their designated buyer purchases the home at the predetermined buyout price, less any fees the contract allows. If a condition was not met, such as declining a qualifying offer or skipping a required price reduction, the guarantee may no longer apply.
Guaranteed sale offers are not generally prohibited in Florida, but real estate advertising should not be misleading and the terms should be spelled out clearly in a written agreement. Florida real estate licensees are regulated by the Florida Real Estate Commission. Have a Florida real estate attorney review any guarantee contract before you sign.
Price it accurately from day one, prepare it well, and market it aggressively to local and relocating buyers. A correctly priced home with strong marketing often sells quickly without the steep discount built into most guarantee programs. Results depend on the individual property, location, and current market conditions. Not necessarily. The promise is usually written into a real contract. The problem is that the guaranteed price is often well below market value and comes with conditions, such as an agent-set list price, scheduled price cuts, higher fees or a requirement to buy your next home through the same team. Get the terms in writing and compare them with a standard listing before you sign.
A guaranteed sale is a listing with a backup buyout: the agent tries to sell on the open market first and only buys if the home does not sell by a deadline. An instant cash offer skips the listing: a company buys the home directly, charges a service fee and deducts repairs. Both trade some of your equity for certainty, so compare the net amount you would keep.
Don’t fall for the bait and switch. If someone has offered to sell your home or buy it, let’s put their promise next to real St. Pete and Tampa Bay sales data. I will give you a straight answer on what your home is likely worth, what each option would actually net you, and whether any guarantee is worth what it costs. No pressure, no fluff, just honest local guidance.The Better Guarantee: Price It Right and Market It Hard
FAQ: Guaranteed Sale Programs
Want a Real Number Instead of a Gimmick?
Awesome!!! This is a great article… well done.